The Girl in the Tower | Katherine Arden

by - December 18, 2019

"A woman married. Or she became a nun. Or she died. That was what being a woman meant."

lithereal, book review,

"The Girl in the Tower" is the second book in the Winternight trilogy, following the brilliant "The Bear and the Nightingale." Picking up the plot thread of the previous boo right where it was left off, it is an exciting, adventurous and dangerous tale of a Russian girl determined to carve her own way.

Vasya cannot stay in her village, pronounced a witch, so she decides to become a traveler and see the world. After a tense visit to Morozko who again tries to convince her to stay home and live out her life as "women should", she sets out on her journey. She poses as a boy, naming herself Vasilii Petrovich, in order to pass by more inconspicuously. Still, it is Vasya and her curiosity and restless spirit have to read their head.

"Things made by effort are more real than things made by wishing."

On the other side of the story we have Olya, Vasya's sister, the Princess of Serpukhov, a mother of two, pregnant with her third child and a  mistress of her own estate. Her young daughter Masha has nightmares about seeing a ghost and she is trying to console the child as best she can amid her other duties. There's also Sasha, Brother Aleksandr Peresvet, Vasya's older brother who left Lesnaya Zemlya to become a monk. He is the Grand Prince's advisor and has been spying on the Tartars in a secret mission in Sarai.

A chase after a group of bandits who burn villages and kidnap young girls unites the characters and the storyline, resolving some issues while creating a whole new set of other, ones that might be even more dangerous. Caught in Vasys'a lie about her gender and name, Sasha and Olya are helpless for they cannot expose her, nor can they let her go on pretending to be someone she's not. 

Another danger lurks in the shadows... Vasya is warned multiple times by the cheryeti that they will all be watching, but she ignores their warning and prophecies. Yet, why does she feel this strange fear whenever she is in the presence of Kasyan Lutovich? A boyar whom no one knows, but who came to ask Dmitrii Ivanovich for help with the bandit problem, he seems to be everywhere and you soon get the feeling that something is not right, even though, for all intents and purposes he seems to do the right things and say the right words.

"Only boys and fool think mean are first in courage. We do not bear children."

In this book, alliances are tested, the battle between the old and the new gods is still going on, the new friends Vasya met are in danger of disappearing. The old character are here, too. Morozko is still helping out Vasya, despite is disapproval and the promises that it won't happen again. I was pleasantly surprised by some kisses the pair exchanged, even though at the end it all seems desolate. I love how he actually knows she won't listen to him, that she will go her won way and then tries to be there for her as much as he can. Neither of them are perfect but it feels like they accept each other.

So, I loved the book. Absolutely adored it. The storytelling was superb, the writing magnificent and once again, I felt transported into the settings. The one gripe I have, and it's really only a personal preference, is Vasya's recklessness. I understand that it is in her nature, that's she's always been fearless, that she longs to be free, but somehow, as I was reading what she was doing and saying while impersonating Vasilii the Brave, I wanted to step into the story and slap her. She constantly ignores any counsel from people who mean her well, lets herself be manipulated because of her competitive nature, endangers her family with her recklessness and has several tantrums that don't make too much sense to me. But - she is a teenager, and this is a story of growing up, so I accepted these choices, though I was really irritated by her behavior. Again, this has nothing to do with the quality of the story, I simply wanted to point out that there were times when I slammed the book shut and wanted to throw it across the room. (I didn't. It's too pretty and too good to just throw around.)

"Every time you take one path, you must live with the memory of the other: of a life left unchosen."

Anyway, that is kind of the thing about this book. I loved it, but just as you are annoyed by certain traits of the people you love, I had my issues with Vasya. I accept her as she is but I don't approve of all her actions. The story itself is brilliant, the universe is expanding, the stakes are getting higher and the author writes about the medieval world of Rus' so poignantly that it feels as if you're right there with the characters. Everything feels real, even though there's magic and mythical creatures abound. Be sure to pick up this book and follow Vasya on the continuation of her journey. As for me, I'm getting right into the third book.

You May Also Like

0 comments