the sunday lit

instagram pinterest goodreads tumblr
    • Home
    • About
    • Contact
"I am a witch. I have plucked snowdrops at Midwinter, died at my own choosing, and wept for a nightingale. Now I am beyond prophecy."

lithereal, book review,

And here it is... the last book in the trilogy. I took up reading it with both excitement and sadness. Excitement of course because I get to see how this thrilling story ends, but  the sadness was because of the ending. After the ~350 pages in front of me, there would be no more to read. But, let's get through it.

The story starts just where the last book left off. The city of Moscow is burning and people are looking for someone to blame. Father Konstantin, spurred on by Medved, readily takes up the story that it's all the witch's fault. And so Vasya, not knowing what else to do in order to spare her family, surrenders herself to the mob. They beat her and the priest even slays her (and my) beloved horse Solovey. Dejected, Vasya is lead to the river where she is to be burned as a witch.

"She felt like a girl hurled unwary into a tale she didn't understand, with folk all around, waiting for her to take up a part she didn't know."

An unexpected chyert comes to her aid, but she refuses to join him, running away with Olya's servant who takes her on the road to Midnight. There, Vasya wanders but thankfully manages to find friends who lead her to the house by the lake. She takes refuge there and learns more about her ancestry, and her powers. We are introduced to more characters, like Pozhar - a mare that is actually a firebird, the same one that burned down Moscow; or Ded Grib - a mushroom that joins Vasya's cause. Polunochnitsa is also a bigger character here and her method of being helpful is... questionable. Still, they are all interesting, all with distinct personalities and I have a place in my heart for them all.

But things are just getting stared. Medved is wrecking havoc in Moscow and Morozko seems to have sacrificed his freedom in order to let his brother out so he might come to Vasya's aid. The winter king is bound somewhere "beyond recall: long ago and far away and deep in the dark that does not change". She does manage to get to him, and it is one of my favorite moments in the book. Their romance is a slow-burn, but a really good one, and I always appreciated how much he respected her, let her make her own choices, despite not wanting her to get involved in any of it.

"That way lies evil, when men put themselves too high, saying, I know what God wants, for it is what I want."

On the other side, there is another war in Russia: between the Rus' and the Tatars. The conflict is unavoidable when their last resort at putting it off is thwarted by Medved's scheming. Dmitrii is preparing for war, and Sasha is trying to keep his place as the Grand Prince's advisor. The Golden Horse far outnumbers the army of the Rus' but they must march on and fight for freedom, for survival. All of Russia must come together: men and cheryeti alike, to save the soil that bore them.

I loved this book as a conclusion to the story, and it is so obvious how planned they are, how much research the author has done in order to make the whole world seem real. Vasya is much more mature, less reckless here - and I truly appreciate that she has learned from her mistakes, because there were some things I wanted to yell about in the last book. She really comes into her own, but must pace herself and be careful, because in this universe magic makes you go mad. I truly appreciate that there music be some kind of sacrifice for everything, that she is not just given these powers. It makes her story seem more human, and more realistic, despite the world it is set in.

"I will think of the future to remind me that the present is not forever."

Another thing I appreciate is how no one got the point to any of it. The fight between Medved and Morozko has always been the forefront, always the good vs the bad. But who decides this? How do we know who is good and who is bad, really? This twist really stunned me, because no one can tell this to Vasya, she has to come to understand it on her own. The whole point was to unite against a common enemy, not squabble among each other like children. And when Vasya realizes this, everything falls into place.

The ending is bitter-sweet. Vasya notes that they might have reached their goal, but the price was too high. Still, life goes on and, going forward, she can only try to keep the peace, keep the whole of Rus' united. Now, having read all of the story, I simply cannot find the adequate words to describe how much I love it. Please, go read it, immerse yourself in this amazing world that makes me want to book a ticked to Russia and go wandering the snow-covered forests, looking for a winter-king.

"Love is for those who know the griefs of time, for it goes hand in hand with loss."
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
No comments
"A woman married. Or she became a nun. Or she died. That was what being a woman meant."

lithereal, book review,

"The Girl in the Tower" is the second book in the Winternight trilogy, following the brilliant "The Bear and the Nightingale." Picking up the plot thread of the previous boo right where it was left off, it is an exciting, adventurous and dangerous tale of a Russian girl determined to carve her own way.

Vasya cannot stay in her village, pronounced a witch, so she decides to become a traveler and see the world. After a tense visit to Morozko who again tries to convince her to stay home and live out her life as "women should", she sets out on her journey. She poses as a boy, naming herself Vasilii Petrovich, in order to pass by more inconspicuously. Still, it is Vasya and her curiosity and restless spirit have to read their head.

"Things made by effort are more real than things made by wishing."

On the other side of the story we have Olya, Vasya's sister, the Princess of Serpukhov, a mother of two, pregnant with her third child and a  mistress of her own estate. Her young daughter Masha has nightmares about seeing a ghost and she is trying to console the child as best she can amid her other duties. There's also Sasha, Brother Aleksandr Peresvet, Vasya's older brother who left Lesnaya Zemlya to become a monk. He is the Grand Prince's advisor and has been spying on the Tartars in a secret mission in Sarai.

A chase after a group of bandits who burn villages and kidnap young girls unites the characters and the storyline, resolving some issues while creating a whole new set of other, ones that might be even more dangerous. Caught in Vasys'a lie about her gender and name, Sasha and Olya are helpless for they cannot expose her, nor can they let her go on pretending to be someone she's not. 

Another danger lurks in the shadows... Vasya is warned multiple times by the cheryeti that they will all be watching, but she ignores their warning and prophecies. Yet, why does she feel this strange fear whenever she is in the presence of Kasyan Lutovich? A boyar whom no one knows, but who came to ask Dmitrii Ivanovich for help with the bandit problem, he seems to be everywhere and you soon get the feeling that something is not right, even though, for all intents and purposes he seems to do the right things and say the right words.

"Only boys and fool think mean are first in courage. We do not bear children."

In this book, alliances are tested, the battle between the old and the new gods is still going on, the new friends Vasya met are in danger of disappearing. The old character are here, too. Morozko is still helping out Vasya, despite is disapproval and the promises that it won't happen again. I was pleasantly surprised by some kisses the pair exchanged, even though at the end it all seems desolate. I love how he actually knows she won't listen to him, that she will go her won way and then tries to be there for her as much as he can. Neither of them are perfect but it feels like they accept each other.

So, I loved the book. Absolutely adored it. The storytelling was superb, the writing magnificent and once again, I felt transported into the settings. The one gripe I have, and it's really only a personal preference, is Vasya's recklessness. I understand that it is in her nature, that's she's always been fearless, that she longs to be free, but somehow, as I was reading what she was doing and saying while impersonating Vasilii the Brave, I wanted to step into the story and slap her. She constantly ignores any counsel from people who mean her well, lets herself be manipulated because of her competitive nature, endangers her family with her recklessness and has several tantrums that don't make too much sense to me. But - she is a teenager, and this is a story of growing up, so I accepted these choices, though I was really irritated by her behavior. Again, this has nothing to do with the quality of the story, I simply wanted to point out that there were times when I slammed the book shut and wanted to throw it across the room. (I didn't. It's too pretty and too good to just throw around.)

"Every time you take one path, you must live with the memory of the other: of a life left unchosen."

Anyway, that is kind of the thing about this book. I loved it, but just as you are annoyed by certain traits of the people you love, I had my issues with Vasya. I accept her as she is but I don't approve of all her actions. The story itself is brilliant, the universe is expanding, the stakes are getting higher and the author writes about the medieval world of Rus' so poignantly that it feels as if you're right there with the characters. Everything feels real, even though there's magic and mythical creatures abound. Be sure to pick up this book and follow Vasya on the continuation of her journey. As for me, I'm getting right into the third book.
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
No comments
"Lights flickered invitingly behind its lowered blinds and its yellow walls and steeply pitched red roof made Bo think of fairy-tale cottages and gingerbread houses."

lithereal, book review,

Boughey, known as Bo, is a 26-year-old hip Londoner. She loves living in the City, has a good job, even though she isn't really thrilled about doing it, lives in a small flat (but at least away from her parents) with her best friend and has her eye on a new colleague. Ben, though, insists on keeping their relationship a secret so things wouldn't be awkward at the office. The dissatisfaction with her circumstances make Bo feel as though she's headed for a quarter life crisis.

But when she is made redundant at her firm, her life spirals. he's held onto the reigns tightly, and now feels like an utter loser. Kirsten, her friend, convinces her to go to Aslbrog, a small town in Denmark where her mother owns a cabin, to de-stress and find her equilibrium. To her surprise, the cabin has a few more guests, friends of Kirsten mom's, but Bo soon learns that some company might be good for her soul, especially when Emil comes knocking at the door.

"Hygge is about the shared experience, not the end result."

Now, I must say I did not enjoy the book too much. The whole fist part with the office gossip and her "relationship" with Ben, her obsession with him... Well, it got annoying way too fast. It is obvious to the reader he is using her, though somehow not to her and her constant worrying about what he's doing, stalking him on social media, wallowing - well, it gets old. Her obtuse refusal to see him for what he is and the self-esteem issues unfortunately failed to make her more sympathetic to me. I wanted to smack her upside the head and yell at her to open her eyes. She also jumps into a relationship with Emil with no thought about Ben - even though they haven't broken up yet, and even though she's been miserable about his lack of affection 20 pages earlier.

Another thing that struck me and was the pacing. The first, boring, part of the book dragged on way too much. The part in the summerhouse was too short, and especially the ending which felt like extended bullet points. The whole premise of the book is her going to Denmark, learning about hygge and starting to appreciate the simpler things in life, starting to move slower and take in the life going on around her. There was also something frustrating about Bo as a character as well, that I just cannot pin down exactly, that made me not root for her, made me not care if she got her happy ending. When it came in the end it felt rushed and unearned.

"It occurred to her that for the first time in ages, she felt completely at ease, not just with the people around her, but with herself."

The things I wrote in my notebook while reading: "Idiot." "She's petulant." "Annoying and stupid." "All her choices are motivated by this jerk (Ben)." "She's a mess - acts like a teenager." "Just making a spectacle of herself." "Stop whining." So yeah... I did not really like Bo.

Still, it's a cute book, and a quick read for winter - especially with the descriptions of the Denmark cabin and landscape Those are my favorite chapters, to be honest and I felt like much more of the book should have been about that journey to discovery Bo undertakes in Aslbrog.
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
No comments
“I’ve seen enough in this world to know that two people who can make each other that miserable must love each other a lot.”

lithereal, book review,

Tom Langdon is 41, a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist, a globetrotter, a roaming soul... and he's taking a train from DC to LA this Christmas. Intent on writing a story about train travel and fulfilling a long-standing family wish, he prepares himself for the ride on two historic trains - The Capitol Limited and The Southwest Chief.

His current girlfriend, though mostly just casual partner, Lelia is a voice actress. Their relationship is nothing like what he had so long ago, back when he had an actual partner, a woman he wanted forever with... before she left him in Tel Aviv, the words she said that day still not making sense in his head.

“Love is like a good piece of wood: It just gets stronger and stronger as the years go by.”

The train ride proves to be a much bigger adventure than he had anticipated, though. With a cast of characters so colorful: 
  • the train attendants Regina and her mother Roxanne, always ready with good advice and with a way to fix any crisis; 
  • the old train man Higgings who was let go because of budget costs but travels on his own budget and still consults he conductor; 
  • Agnes Joe, a fat lady who is always intruding on everything, knows and is known by everyone, always travels but apparently has nowhere to go to; 
  • Father Kelly, a priest who has retired but still likes giving advice and is somewhat lost in life; 
  • Gordon Merrywather, "the king of class-action lawsuit";
  • Steve and Julie, a young couple who decides to elope despite their parents' disapproval; 
  • Misty, a New Orleans native who reads Tarot cards; 
  • Max Powers, a famous Hollywood director; 
  • Kristobal, his assistant.
And then there is Eleanor. She's writing the script for Max's new movie and Tom is left speechless and numb when he sees the love of his life for the fist time after all those years.

“I’m not saying that riding the train will change your life, or that passenger rail will be a big moneymaker one day. But no matter how fast we feel we have to go, shouldn’t there be room for a train, where you can just sit back, take a breath, and be human for a little while? Just for a little while? Is that so bad?”

There are a lot of adventures on the train: a wedding, a loose boa constrictor, a thief, an angry lawyer, new passengers, an avalanche... And through it all, the people on board lean on each other, help and become a makeshift family. Tom and Eleanor learn to communicate because it's their lack of skill in that department that got them to a breaking point in Tel Aviv many years ago.

But through all the adventure and fun, will these two learn to just be with each other? Will they be able to let go of their hurts and simply love? Well, the other people on the train are certainly going to give their best to make them see they are meant fr each other, some more than others... and the reveal at the end will help you see how much people care.

There is also a Hallmark movie based on the book. I saw it before reading but they are different enough that the book experience wasn't soiled. I knew about the twist at the end, but there were so many more characters and twists that I was kept on the edge of my seat wondering if the reveal is the same. And though it was, it is handled differently so now I can enjoy both mediums because they provide different experiences.

This is a wonderful Christmas book and, not gonna lie, it made me want to get on a long distance train and just soak up the atmosphere, observe people and take in the adventure. Maybe I'll even do it someday.
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
No comments
"They only come for the wild maiden."

lithereal, book review,

The old and the new gods are battling in the Russian north. It all starts with a story, a legend.

Marina and Pyotr have four children - a daughter, Olga, and three sons: Nikolai, Aleksandr and Alyosha. But soon Marina feels a quickening in her womb and feels that somehow this is the child she has been waiting for. This is the child she wants for herself, the one she must have, a daughter that will take after her mother.

Vasilisa Petrovna, Vasya, comes into the world just as her mother leaves it. She is an ugly child, with eyes too large, arms and legs too long, feet too big, all around too much. She is a headstrong girl, not afraid to look anyone in the eye, with no shyness that is expected of women, no qualms about doing what he wants at the bewilderment and censorship from the whole village.

Her father, Pyotr, soon realizes that he should get married again because someone needs to take care of the child. Her older sister is to be married and Dunya, the elderly caretaker is getting too old to care for a young, roguish child. So he goes to that capital and brings back Anna Ivanovna.

"I am a  mare to him. And if a mare will not yield to a harness, well, he will make her."

Anna is... strange. She wanted to go to the monastery because the church is the only place where she doesn't see "the devils". But when she is reluctantly married off ("to be some lord's breeding sow") and comes to the icy north where the old legends and the old gods are still revered she goes crazy. The fact that little Vasya seems to also see these creatures and is talking to them makes her even more irritable.

Convinced that Vasya will bring doom to them all, she urges Pyotr to marry her off, just get her away from their village. When the new priest, the lethally handsome Konstantin, comes to the village Vasya is vilified even more. Her refusal of behaving like a girl "should" chafes the young priest who is used to people venerating him, who is used to having people's attention, their love and fear. But Vasya will have none of it.

"It is a cruel task, to frighten people in God's name. I leave it to you." She hesitated and added, very softly. "However, Batyushka, I am not afraid."

On the other side of the human struggles, there is a whole magical world. The old gods who have guarded the people against evil for centuries are now in peril of dying out because the priest has made people afraid, has made them worship the Christian god and abandon their long-time protectors. It is these little creatures that Vasya and Anna can see, thought they have utterly different reactions to them.

Being the one that sees them, and doesn't fear them, Vasya takes care of the spirits, talks to them and learns from their wisdom. She is entangled in a fight for the survival of he whole nation and it is exactly the things that made her an outcast that help her then. She is willing to see beyond what is expected and her courage and defiance help her see her goal through.

"But I think you should be careful, Batyushka, that God does not speak in the voice of your own wishing."

An element that I noticed throughout the story is the vilification of women. Whenever anything goes wrong, it must be a woman's fault. She is accused of being a witch and is ostracized or sentenced to death. In this story Vasya is given the option of becoming a nun or dying in the cold forest ("I must be a man's servant and a mare for his pleasure, or I must hide myself behind walls and surrender my flesh to a cold, silent god.") These are the patterns we still see, throwing all the blame on women, somehow always making them the source of evil, even in the most banal cases. A woman's place is in the home, with a husband and kids, and nothing else will fulfill her, right? Even in our modern society where women can have careers, the ones who do not seek to have traditional female roles in their private lives are somehow the reason for the apocalypse. And it is so nice to a see a woman, even in a book, not caring about any of it, simply following her path and pressing on until she realizes her full potential.

Anyway, read this book, don't you dare skip it. I will be reading the two sequels this month as well, so look out for that too. And, go - read.
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
No comments
Newer Posts
Older Posts

About Me



I blog from time to time about things that inspire me. Lately, I have been getting back into the habit of reading, and my posts reflect that. I'm also always trying to take pretty photos, with varying degrees of success.


Follow

Follow

Blog Archive

  • ►  2025 (17)
    • ►  March (8)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (3)
  • ►  2024 (60)
    • ►  December (9)
    • ►  November (6)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (7)
    • ►  July (6)
    • ►  June (6)
    • ►  May (1)
    • ►  April (4)
    • ►  March (4)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (3)
  • ►  2023 (13)
    • ►  November (3)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  April (1)
    • ►  February (1)
  • ►  2022 (6)
    • ►  February (4)
    • ►  January (2)
  • ►  2021 (4)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  June (1)
    • ►  April (1)
    • ►  January (1)
  • ►  2020 (31)
    • ►  December (6)
    • ►  November (9)
    • ►  October (8)
    • ►  August (3)
    • ►  July (2)
    • ►  June (2)
    • ►  March (1)
  • ▼  2019 (13)
    • ▼  December (5)
      • The Winter of the Witch | Katherine Arden
      • The Girl in the Tower | Katherine Arden
      • Hygge and Kisses | Clara Christensen
      • The Christmas Train | David Baldacci
      • The Bear and the Nightingale | Katherine Arden
    • ►  November (5)
    • ►  October (2)
    • ►  July (1)
  • ►  2018 (21)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (2)
    • ►  September (3)
    • ►  August (4)
    • ►  July (4)
    • ►  June (2)
    • ►  May (1)
    • ►  April (1)
  • ►  2017 (1)
    • ►  December (1)
  • ►  2016 (1)
    • ►  February (1)

Created with by BeautyTemplates