The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year | Ally Carter

by - January 04, 2025

                     

"you know, if mankind has one universal superpower, it’s gaslighting women into thinking they’re the problem. you were never supposed to do more than he did. you weren’t supposed to be more. you sure as hell weren’t supposed to earn more."

    This is a locked-room mystery about an eighty-one-year-old crime queen’s mysterious disappearance in the middle of a blizzard from her own study without leaving a trace, all signs pointing to a perpetrator who has been threatening her life for a long time.

    So, what happens when hot hunk Ethan and recently divorced Maggie, both writers at the same publishing house, get invited to spend Christmas with a fan who turns out to be Maggie’s favorite author, Eleanor? And, why did Eleanor choose to invite Ethan and Maggie particularly to what has been an annual traditional holiday family gathering only? And, while readers are taking in the ambiance of Eleanor’s castle, and all her quirky relatives and other guests, why and how did Eleanor suddenly disappear in the midst of a blizzard? Was she murdered? Is there something sinister going on? If so, why? And, who is behind it? Or, is this a contest for the mystery authors to solve for some unknown purpose?
    
    Maggie Chase, a successful cozy mystery writer, has had some rough times around Christmas. She endured the loss of both her parents and her husband leaving her for her best friend. Yes, she did catch them in flagrante delicto. And yes, they were assholes. As Christmas approached, her publisher advised that her presence was required at a party in England, hosted by a fan. Though very reluctant, Maggie decided to go. When she arrived, she discovered that the host was none other than Eleanor Ashley, the renowned mystery author, and her idol.

    The guest list included rival writer Ethan Wyatt, which she found out aboard the plane. The two do not see eye-to-eye, and as we are watching the story unfold through Maggie’s eyes – it seems Eathan hates her and feels himself superior. But he doesn't seem to understand what he has done to make Maggie hate him as much as she does. He has been running with this joke that he thinks she remembers (calling her Marcie) but clearly she doesn't. He will, however, never forget because it originated on the first day he met her. When she changed his life. But then, just after the elevator, he found out she was married. And now she is divorced and a shell of herself. Now, stuck with her in this mansion, he is determined to get to the bottom of this misunderstanding between them.

    The two find themselves with some of Eleanor’s relatives gathered for the holidays at her grand mansion. As the group is stranded by a snowstorm, eighty-one-year-old Eleanor mysteriously disappears. Maggie assumes this is all a clever game. Being an Eleanor Ashley superfan and fellow mystery writer, she follows a breadcrumb trail of clues, while using passages from Eleanor's novels in conjunction with her current work in progress to unravel the mystery, only to discover that someone has been trying to kill Eleanor for weeks. But when a guest is poisoned, things get serious. With Ethan, whom she detests but needs to trust, Maggie tries to figure out what happened to Eleanor and to uncover the villain in a household of likely suspects, most of whom have a motive. And could Ethan's charms also be softening Maggie's heart? 

    As they sort through the clues, explore the mansion and encounter various dangers, Eathan slowly starts to peel away his past for Maggie. He lets her in unlike anyone else has been let in in a long time. All while trying to keep her safe as she is prancing around this mansion acting like a detective in one of her books. But she is smiling and laughing, looking invigorated by revealing the clues of this puzzle, and he finds himself falling even more. Things come to a head when Maggie is taken and they still don't know who is behind all of the mayhem. One thing he does know is that Maggie is not going to get hurt. He will die making sure she stays safe and maybe there’s a chance that not only will they walk away but they will walk away together.

    The story is a sort of  inside a mystery as Maggie and Ethan are summoned to solve Eleanor’s murder, but also what it is that’s gone so wrong between them. The locked door mystery was very intriguing and involved more twists than I expected and I loved the setting and the circumstances that brought them to the remote English estate. It was cozy and still with this element of tension that pierced through the holiday calm. Absolutely loved this and would read more Christmas novels of this ilk.

You May Also Like

0 comments